| |
|
|
Business Stationary Mart - The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable
|
List Price: $26.95
Our Price: $15.49
Your Save: $ 11.46 ( 43% )
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
Manufacturer: Random House
|
Average Customer Rating:   
|
|
Binding: Hardcover
Dewey Decimal Number: 003.54
EAN: 9781400063512
ISBN: 1400063515
Label: Random House
Manufacturer: Random House
Number Of Items: 1
Number Of Pages: 400
Publication Date: 2007-04-17
Publisher: Random House
Release Date: 2007-04-17
Studio: Random House
|
|
|
|
|
|
Spotlight customer reviews:
|
Customer Rating:
Summary: Pompous and annoying
Comment: As others have observed, there are a couple of good ideas in this book. The style, however, makes it practically unreadable. I actually listened to the audiobook; one of the editorial reviews comments that the reader salvaged the work somewhat by softening the sarcastic and annoying tone; I did not find that to be the case. It's hard to blame the narrator, as he seems to have captured more-or-less the author's intent.
The "couple of good ideas" are fairly straightforward. One, don't assume that you know the form of the probability distribution of any given social or economic phenomenon. That's good advice. It's often easy to find a function and a set of parameters that appear to fit a given historical data set; but just because the function appears to fit historically doesn't mean it's going to be predictive. Two, if the form of the distribution is unknown and unknowable, then computed measures of "risk" are not reliable, as risk is in fact incalculable. So, a good investing strategy is to avoid assets whose valuation depends on risk estimates, and seek out certain other assets. Following that strategy would have kept you out of a lot of the asset classes that have melted down recently.
The most frustrating problem with the way the book is written is its lack of self-consistency. For example, there is a long discussion of "silent evidence": just because you don't observe something doesn't mean it's not there. Then, over and over again, Taleb tries to assert that no one in business, or the social sciences, or this or that domain understands a certain issue correctly. Even if we assume for a moment that Taleb's understanding of the point in question is correct, and that he is therefore qualified to pass judgement on who is a Right-Thinking Individual, the fact that he has not encountered any Right-Thinking Individuals does not mean they don't exist. He may not have met them; or he may have met them and not been listening when they spoke; or he may have met them and presented his ideas in such a contemptuous way they chose not to engage in conversation, concluding there would be no value to themselves in it.
Then there is the rant against the bell curve that occupies the last chapters of the book. Kind of silly to get angry at a mathematical function. It's like criticizing a hammer for not being a screwdriver. In a few places the author does draw the distinction between appropriate uses of the bell curve and inappropriate uses, which is of course the (perfectly reasonable) point he is trying to make. Most of this section, however, is written in a much more sloppy and imprecise way, so that any sentence or paragraph by itself comes across as criticizing the hammer. To make sense of it one has to keep saying to oneself "well what he really means is that there are certain people who misuse this tool, and they shouldn't."
Similarly, the assault on academic economics and the Nobel Prize. Not many people would argue that idealized models are predictive of reality. That's not the same as saying they are without value; it just means one has to know what to use them for. The author does find value in behavioral economics, but somehow when attacking academia seems to forget that a) behavioral economics is all the rage today in academic circles, and b) the Nobel committee, who Taleb considers so clueless, awarded Kahneman the economics prize for inventing it. [Another self-consistency issue here: after a very lengthy discursion on the value of empiricism and the fallacy of oversimplified models, Taleb confidently repeats numerous experimental-psychology and behavioral-economics results as "the way we behave," where by "we" he means all of humanity, excluding perhaps himself the Enlightened One. In fact, most of these results are based on very small samples, so while they are indeed interesting, the authors generally go to great lengths to explain that what they have observed COULD have a certain meaning or cause, but that the data are not conclusive, as other causes could have led to the same observations.]
Great books are like great friends. Even when they challenge your ideas, you want to enage with them because it's such a pleasure. This is not such a book. The ideas, while interesting, are not as controversial as the author claims, and they aren't worth the pain of struggling through the writing.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Great idea - mediocre presentation
Comment: I listened to the audiobook. I think the idea behind this book is very, very interesting - life is shaped more by random (non-predictable) events than by anything one of us can foresee. That being said, the author has filled the book with several anecdotes that are somewhat meaningless (eg, the fictitious Russian author) and/or irrelevant (autobiographical details of his life) - hence the 4 stars, rather than the 5 stars the idea deserves. It appears that at times, he is trying to be too clever by half, and destroys the rhythm of ideas by being too verbose. Some of his sentences are very convoluted, and I found myself having to rewind and listen to some sentences more than once to figure out what he means by what he says. I found the parallels with Asimov's futuristic science fiction Foundation series- where Harry Seldon constructs his of mathematically predicting the future, but is thrown off by the unpredictable appearance of the Mule (=a black swan). It is odd, especially in the context of this book, that over so many millennia that the Foundation existed, why only one such even that was so enormously disruptive occurred. According to Taleb, they should be occurring much more commonly. Had this book been written better, I would have given it 5 stars.
Customer Rating:
Summary: The Black Swan is a Red Herring
Comment: Nicholas Taleb has seemingly spent his entire life chasing what he refers to as the black swan. A series of highly improbable events that have continuously shaped the course of human history. He presents his description of this phenomenon in what might be termed an autobiographical manifesto of sorts, the exhaustive and seemingly endlessly referenced book, "The Black Swan -- The Impact of the Highly Improbable". It's not that Taleb isn't onto something, or hasn't written a thought provoking book, he has. But Taleb has not given us a black swan. He has given us a Red Herring. He has taken a small piece of stinky fish and dragged it in the dirt perpendicular to the path we are on. There is a small benefit, if we leave our path momentarily to gain a new perspective, new insights will emerge, but that is all our feeble brains can comprehend, and nothing more. But to believe there are no thinker's among us who do not understand the need to search for the extraordinary and to try to link them to potential causes, that although we might not understand completely, are contributory and can indeed be rectified, is not to be an observer of the human race at all. Ultimately he is wrong about the Black Swan but he is right about the requirement for us to think outside the box. But this has been said before. Taleb just reminds us.
Customer Rating:
Summary: First 2 chapters are worth the price
Comment: The research based information on the psychology of marketing, buying and selling that are described in the first two chapters are little known, facinating and extremely useful for those at many levels. Detailed discussions of "decoys" in marketing products, the relative comparisons involved in almost all buying decisions and the incredible effects of "free" merchandise such as Amazon's free shipping are given in an interesting and engaging way. After that the impact and interest of the information declines with each chapter and by chapter 7 it is hard to tell what the focus of the book (audio) is. A guess would be that after chapter three it just goes on to whatever the author found interesting and researched.
Customer Rating:
Summary: A great book long over due
Comment: The author, I think, is one of the great thinkers of our time. I enjoyed his work. On YouTube, there is a long interview of Mr. Taleb by an old guy. It was a disaster in that the interviewer has almost no knowledge about what what Taleb was talking about (including chaos, ...) and consistently interrupts and makes annoying noises. Therefore, I could only partially tell what Taleb was trying to say and I knew it was something important. Being unable to completely hear and see what Taleb attempted to say, I bought his book. Anyhow, it is not a technical book, it's fun with lots of history knowledge and intriging to read. I recommended it to many friends already.
|
|
|
Editorial Reviews:
|
Bestselling author Nassim Nicholas Taleb continues his exploration of randomness in his fascinating new book, The Black Swan, in which he examines the influence of highly improbable and unpredictable events that have massive impact. Engaging and enlightening, The Black Swan is a book that may change the way you think about the world, a book that Chris Anderson calls, "a delightful romp through history, economics, and the frailties of human nature." See Anderson's entire guest review below.
Guest Reviewer: Chris Anderson
 Chris Anderson is editor-in-chief of Wired magazine and the author of The Long Tail: Why the Future of Business Is Selling Less of More.
Four hundred years ago, Francis Bacon warned that our minds are wired to deceive us. "Beware the fallacies into which undisciplined thinkers most easily fall--they are the real distorting prisms of human nature." Chief among them: "Assuming more order than exists in chaotic nature." Now consider the typical stock market report: "Today investors bid shares down out of concern over Iranian oil production." Sigh. We're still doing it.
Our brains are wired for narrative, not statistical uncertainty. And so we tell ourselves simple stories to explain complex thing we don't--and, most importantly, can't--know. The truth is that we have no idea why stock markets go up or down on any given day, and whatever reason we give is sure to be grossly simplified, if not flat out wrong.
Nassim Nicholas Taleb first made this argument in Fooled by Randomness, an engaging look at the history and reasons for our predilection for self-deception when it comes to statistics. Now, in The Black Swan: the Impact of the Highly Improbable, he focuses on that most dismal of sciences, predicting the future. Forecasting is not just at the heart of Wall Street, but it's something each of us does every time we make an insurance payment or strap on a seat belt.
The problem, Nassim explains, is that we place too much weight on the odds that past events will repeat (diligently trying to follow the path of the "millionaire next door," when unrepeatable chance is a better explanation). Instead, the really important events are rare and unpredictable. He calls them Black Swans, which is a reference to a 17th century philosophical thought experiment. In Europe all anyone had ever seen were white swans; indeed, "all swans are white" had long been used as the standard example of a scientific truth. So what was the chance of seeing a black one? Impossible to calculate, or at least they were until 1697, when explorers found Cygnus atratus in Australia.
Nassim argues that most of the really big events in our world are rare and unpredictable, and thus trying to extract generalizable stories to explain them may be emotionally satisfying, but it's practically useless. September 11th is one such example, and stock market crashes are another. Or, as he puts it, "History does not crawl, it jumps." Our assumptions grow out of the bell-curve predictability of what he calls "Mediocristan," while our world is really shaped by the wild powerlaw swings of "Extremistan."
In full disclosure, I'm a long admirer of Taleb's work and a few of my comments on drafts found their way into the book. I, too, look at the world through the powerlaw lens, and I too find that it reveals how many of our assumptions are wrong. But Taleb takes this to a new level with a delightful romp through history, economics, and the frailties of human nature. --Chris Anderson
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
